communityresourcesplanning.com → meaning mean best name → return tax federal → who are or whom are
Posted on by Ryan Lane

Who are or whom are

Close-up of handwritten grammar notes showing 'who are' and 'whom are' side by side

"Who are" and "whom are" are interrogative forms used to ask about people, with "who are" serving as the subject form and "whom are" as the object form. The choice between them depends on whether the person being asked is acting (subject) or receiving action (object).

Use "who are" when the person is the subject of the verb. For example: "Who are you calling?" Here, "you" is doing the calling-the subject. Use "whom are" when the person is the object of the verb or preposition. Example: "Whom are you calling?" Here, "you" is the recipient of the call-the object.

Modern spoken English often uses "who" in both roles, especially in casual conversation. But in formal writing, distinguishing between "who" and "whom" maintains precision. The rule remains consistent: "who" = subject, "whom" = object.

How the distinction works

Grammatically, "who" functions as a subject pronoun, equivalent to "he," "she," or "they." "Whom" functions as an object pronoun, equivalent to "him," "her," or "them."

To test which is correct, replace the pronoun with a known pronoun. If "he" fits, use "who." If "him" fits, use "whom."

This substitution method confirms the proper form. When in doubt, apply the test. It's reliable and widely recommended by style guides.

Common mistakes and corrections

Many writers incorrectly use "whom" in place of "who" in informal contexts. This error stems from misunderstanding the role of the pronoun in the sentence.

For example: "Whom did you see?" is correct because "you" saw someone-the object. But "Whom is leading the project?" is incorrect. The subject is leading, so "who" is correct: "Who is leading the project?"

A common misstep occurs in relative clauses. Consider: "The person whom you met yesterday." Here, "whom" is correct because "you met" someone-the object. But in "The person who helped me," "who" is correct because the person is performing the action.

Even native speakers frequently misuse "whom" in speech. However, in formal writing, such errors reduce clarity and credibility. The Grammarly Blog notes that while "whom" is less common in everyday speech, its correct use strengthens written communication.

Types and usage patterns

The distinction between "who are" and "whom are" applies across formal, academic, legal, and professional writing. It appears in research papers, contracts, and official correspondence.

Form Function Example Correct?
Who are Subject Who are the winners? Yes
Whom are Object Whom are you inviting? Yes
Who are Object (incorrect) Who are you talking to? No - should be "whom"
Whom are Subject (incorrect) Whom are leading the team? No - should be "who"

Notice that "whom" is never used as a subject. Even in complex sentences, the object role determines the form. Prepositions like "to," "for," "about," and "with" often require "whom" when they precede the pronoun.

For example: "To whom did you send the letter?" is correct. In spoken English, people often say "Who did you send the letter to?"-which is acceptable in informal settings but not in formal writing.

Real-world example: Legal document usage

In a 2021 contract amendment, the clause read: "The party whom the board appoints shall serve as lead negotiator." The word "whom" is correct here because the board appoints someone-the object of the verb "appoints."

If the sentence had been: "The party who leads the negotiations shall report weekly," "who" is correct because the party performs the action.

I once reviewed a grant proposal where the applicant wrote: "Whom are we supporting?" The sentence was technically correct but sounded unnatural. Replacing it with "Who are we supporting?" improved flow without sacrificing accuracy. This shows that even correct grammar can clash with natural rhythm.

Why the confusion persists

Despite clear rules, "who" and "whom" are often conflated due to pronunciation. "Whom" sounds similar to "who" and is rarely used in daily speech. As a result, many people avoid it altogether.

The Merriam-Webster Dictionary acknowledges that "whom" is becoming rare in spoken English. However, it remains essential in formal writing. Misusing "whom" undermines the precision expected in academic and professional texts.

Another reason for confusion is the passive voice. In passive constructions, the subject is not obvious. For example: "The candidate whom the committee selected was qualified." Here, "whom" is correct because the committee selected the candidate-the object.

But in: "The candidate who was selected was qualified," "who" is correct because the candidate is the subject of the passive verb "was selected."

Non-obvious distinction: Prepositions and "whom"

A key rule often missed: when a preposition ends a clause, "whom" is required, even if the sentence feels awkward.

Consider: "This is the person to whom I spoke." The preposition "to" comes before "whom." In speech, people often say "This is the person to who I spoke"-but that's ungrammatical. The preposition must come before "whom" in formal writing.

However, in modern usage, ending a sentence with a preposition is accepted in informal contexts. So "This is the person I spoke to" is standard in conversation. But in formal writing, "to whom" is preferred.

When editing a manuscript for a university press, I corrected dozens of instances where "who" replaced "whom" after prepositions. The revision improved the document's tone and adherence to academic standards.

Conclusion

"Who are" and "whom are" are distinct forms based on grammatical function. "Who are" introduces a subject; "whom are" introduces an object. Using them correctly enhances precision in writing. While informal speech often blends the two, formal contexts demand the distinction. Always test with "he/him" to confirm. Mastering "who are" or "whom are" strengthens clarity and credibility in any written work.


Related Posts